NYC, Long Island and The Hamptons Receive Free Delivery on Orders $300+

Perfect Pairings

  1. Five of Dave Sokolin’s Go-To Reds for Summer BBQs

    Five of Dave Sokolin’s Go-To Reds for Summer BBQs

    Five of Dave Sokolin’s Go-To Reds for Summer BBQs

    It’s not summer without a backyard BBQ, and Dave Sokolin is here to share five of his go-to red wines that pair well with summer BBQs. "When I barbecue, I look for something bold that can handle big fire and sauces from being on the grill. I also look for wines with style and subtleties that can shine through. Here are my five picks that I will be barbecuing with this summer, with prices starting at only $31.95." - Dave Sokolin

    2019 Alex Foillard Brouilly - $31.95 | 93 VM - "The king of Beaujolais makes ethereal styled wines." - Dave Sokolin

    2016 Michele Chiarlo Barbaresco Reyna - $37.99 | 94 WE - "This refined Piedmont from the legendary 2016 vintage pairs well with most BBQ ideas." - Dave Sokolin

    2015 Barde Haut - $44.99 | 96 JD – “A classic, 96 point Saint Emilion that drinks great today -

    Read Article
  2. Smoked Salmon Napoleon with Celery Root Chips, Pear-Celery Root Remoulade, and Apple Cider Syrup

    Smoked Salmon Napoleon with Celery Root Chips, Pear-Celery Root Remoulade, and Apple Cider Syrup

    Smoked Salmon Napoleon1. Peel 1 celery root and slice paper thin on a slicing machine if possible
    2. Gently fry in oil until golden brown in color and crispy; season with salt
    3. Alternate layers of celery root chips, celery root remoulade and smoked salmon until three levels are created (a little under an ounce per layer)
    4. Drizzle plate with some fresh apple cider that has been cooked down to a syrup
    5. Garnish with some micro celery or celery leaves

    Celery Root Remoulade:
    Yield: 1 Quart

    Egg yolks- 1 ea.
    Water- ½ T
    Dijon - 1 tsp.
    Oil - ½ C
    Lemon juice - 3T
    Eggs, hard cooked, minced - 1 ea.
    Cornichons, minced - ½ T
    Parsley, minced - ½ T
    Tarragon - 1 tsp.
    Garlic clove, minced - 1 ea.
    Walnuts, toasted - ¼ C
    Celery root,

    Read Article
  3. Grilled Pizza with Prosciutto, Figs and Baby Arugula

    Grilled Pizza with Prosciutto, Figs and Baby Arugula

    Grilled Pizza with ProsciuttoThis recipe for grilled pizza is one of the more popular dishes on the bar menu that we introduced this summer at the Plaza Cafe. We really like the combination of flavors here, and it's a great item for guests to share too.

    Yield: 1 pie

    Onions, sliced, caramelized - 1 ea.
    Fontina, shredded - 6-8 ounces
    Baby arugula - hand full
    Balsamic vinaigrette - 2 ozs.
    Prosciutto, sliced thin - 3 ozs.
    Figs, quartered    - 4 ea.
    Balsamic glaze - as needed

    1. Roll out pizza dough
    2. Brush with oil and place on grill
    3. Once marked, turn over
    4. Top with onions and then fontina
    5. Once fontina is melted, remove from grill
    6. Dress baby arugula with balsamic vinaigrette
    7. Portion baby arugula over fontina
    8. Drape with prosciutto, and then top with figs
    9. Drizzle with balsamic glaze

    Read Article
  4. The Plaza Cafe Lobster Roll

    The Plaza Cafe Lobster Roll

    Plaza Cafe Lobster RollSummer in the Hamptons just isn't summer without a fantastic, fresh lobster roll! This is a summer favorite, and the waters of the East End provide us with very high quality lobster. In celebration of the summer months, The Plaza Café, located in Southampton, created a new bar menu. The lobster roll is a great feature on that menu, and it's become a favorite amongst customers. We have the recipe for you, which is easy to follow and straight forward. Enjoy!

    Yield: 4 orders

    Lobster meat, cooked, diced - 1 pound
    Celery, minced - 1 stalk
    Fennel, stalks, minced - 2 ea.
    Cucumber, seedless, minced - ½ each
    Mayonnaise, preferably homemade* - 1½ cups
    Tarragon, snipped - 2-3 stems
    Brioche hot dog rolls** - 4 ea.

    1. Combine lobster meat with celery, fennel and cucumber.
    2. Gently fold in mayo.
    3. Add tarragon and then lemon juice.
    4. Adjust seasoning

    Read Article
  5. Tuna and Crab Tian with Yuzu Vinaigrette

    Tuna and Crab Tian with Yuzu Vinaigrette

    Tuna and Crab Tian with Yuzu VinaigretteTuna and Crab Tian with Yuzu Vinaigrette is another one of our signature dishes that people ask me about often. I created it a few summers ago specifically for the James Beard Foundation's Chefs & Champagne event honoring Thomas Keller. It has since become a summer staple on our menu at the Plaza Cafe.

    Servings - approx. 4

    Avocado Puree:

    Avocados, ripe - 3 ea.
    Jalapeno, minced - 1 ea.
    Red onion, minced - 1T
    Cilantro, chopped - 2T bunch
    Limes, juice of - 3-4 each
    Olive oil - 2-3 T

    1. Combine all ingredients in a mortar and pestle (or bowl) and mash until well combined; adjust seasoning with salt and pepper.

    Tuna Tartar:
    Tuna, sushi grade, minced - 8 ozs.
    Cucumbers, peeled, minced - 2T
    Scallions, minced - 2T

    Read Article
  6. Strawberry-Rhubarb Crisp

    Strawberry-Rhubarb Crisp

    Strawberry Rhubarb CrispI've always had a fruit crisp on my dessert menu at The Plaza Café, which varies depending on the season. Since local strawberries are currently in season, I thought this was an appropriate fruit crisp to feature now. I've had this particular item on our menu for the past few summer seasons, and it's a great treat! Enjoy!

    Yield: approx. 20

    Strawberries, quartered - 2 quarts
    Rhubarb, 1" dice - 2 pounds
    Lemon juice - 1 T
    Sugar - 1 C
    Cornstarch - 3 T
    Cinnamon - 1tsp.

    1. Marinate strawberries and rhubarb separately with sugar and lemon.
    2. Add cornstarch and cinnamon.
    3. Portion in ramekins, top with Amaretti crumb topping and bake at 350 until golden.

    The Plaza CafeAMARETTI CRUMB TOPPING

    Butter - 1

    Read Article
  7. Seared Diver Sea Scallops with Local Sweet Corn Polenta, Sea Beans, Chanterelles and Basil Oil

    Seared Diver Sea Scallops with Local Sweet Corn Polenta, Sea Beans, Chanterelles and Basil Oil

    Local sea scallops are in season on the East end, and we all love a great scallop dish! The inspiration for the dish was a trip I recently took with a local scallop guy who ran a boat called the Tiny Giant. I was really blown away at how hard this guy worked to get me such a pristine product.  I also really respected the fact that he harvested his catch the old fashioned way without damaging the ocean floor.

    I wanted to come up with a dish that showcased the sweetness and simplicity of these scallops.  At the time, I had a lot of fresh basil in my garden, as well as some great tomatoes and corn to incorporate into this dish.

    (Yield:  4 Entrees)

    Basil Oil: 

    1 bunch basil 
    2 cups grapeseed oil   

    -Blanch and shock basil
    -Puree in blender with oil
    -Let stand overnight and then strain

    Sweet

    Read Article
  8. Sauteed Montauk Striped Bass

    Sauteed Montauk Striped Bass

    Out on the East End of Long Island, we are fortunate to have incredible fish available to us right off of our shore. I initially started to create this dish in an effort to take advantage of our local striped bass run, but the recipe ended up really being a tribute to local bounty on a larger scale. I decided to use potatoes as the building block for the rest of this dish, which is the vegetable the East End is probably most known for. I then thought of our local clams and knew they would make a nice natural broth for the dish that would go well with the potatoes. Although the chorizo is not a local ingredient, I love the way it goes with the clams, and it added a nice kick to the broth. I then took it a step further and added a little of our local calamari to the dish, and that really put it over the top! The sherry vinegar cut through the richness of the dish and balanced it all out. I'd best describe this dish as very simple, clean and a great one for the fall.

    Read Article
  9. Pumpkin-Lobster Bisque

    Pumpkin-Lobster Bisque

    With fall in full swing and Thanksgiving coming up in a few weeks, I thought this Pumpkin-Lobster Bisque Soup would be an ideal recipe to feature now. I actually came up with this recipe a few years ago by chance when making preparations for an Opus Wine dinner menu with Michael Silacci. I needed a first course that paired well with the only white of the evening, a Mondavi Fume Blanc. I initially started to make a traditional pumpkin soup, but it just seemed boring to me. So, to solve that, I blended in some of my lobster sauce and really liked how the two went together. The finishing touch was to butter poach some lobster and add it to the dish to really round it out. This is a great soup to enjoy on cold autumn evenings.

    Yield: 1 gal.

    Lobster, culls - 4 pounds
    Celery, diced    - ½ stalk
    Plum tomatoes, quartered - 2 each
    Shallots, sliced - 3 each
    Garlic, crushed   

    Read Article
  10. Seared Peconic Bay Scallops

    Seared Peconic Bay Scallops

    This Scallop presentation seems to have become one of our signature dishes here at the Plaza Cafe. I remember working as the Banquet Chef for Marriott Corporation many, many years ago and constantly seeing Chicken Piccata on the menu. I got so tired of this preparation that I never wanted to cook this dish again. Needless to say, that flavor profile of acid, capers, butter and so forth stayed in the back of my mind. So when I started thinking of a new way to accentuate the sweetness and texture of our local bounty of scallops, this combination came to mind. Of course it is not a traditional 'Piccata' and is just a play with words, but it did bring back memories. The dish seems to surprise most guests because it doesn't sound like all the ingredients will meld together, but they really do. The cauliflower-white truffle puree adds earthiness to the dish, while the capers add a touch of bitterness and the clementines offer a fresh burst of acidity. However, the real star of the show is by

    Read Article

Need Help Finding the right wine?

Your personal wine consultant will assist you with buying, managing your collection, investing in wine, entertaining and more.

loader
Loading...